It's wild. I did a bunch of really cool acoustics research in my MS program. But couldn't really do anything with it. Now I have a pretty impressive program almost finished that creates a room, a virtual mic array, and very realistically auralizes a source or a combination of sources into your room. I tried to do it 2.5 years ago. Now I have a full pro tools plugin that is fully functional. Still ironing out some kinks. Still a lot of work to get it done, but before it would have been a team of software engineers over a year, now it is just me over a couple months.
I also created a joke one knowb plug-in called "Total Commitment" - 2 settings, Bluegrass me, or Django me. They actually sound really good but there is something very funny in them ;0) I will put it up for free as soon as I get both the MAC and PC version done.
On a side note I think it is only 2-3 years where people like us will be able to do these things. Then it will become SOOOO easy everyone just gets there own software upon request customized to whatever they want to do whenever they want to do it. It still took me some knowledge to guide the AI into all the acoustics programs I made, but it really knew everything, just needed a human to help put some of the pieces together into something more useful.
Classical guitar luthier Gregory Byers worked on compensated nuts/bridge saddles decades ago, using the physics and properties of classical strings and guitars, with experimental data. He came up with his system for improving intonation.. Similar work could be done with, say, Argie 10s and a 670mm scale, given nut height,action, and neck relief. Buzz Feiten also created a system (maybe not scientifically based.)
Your point about the bending seems entirely possible, I don't know. Zero fret guitars should in general be more in tune than a guitar with a nut theoretically but the straight compensation of a gypsy guitar kind of throws that out the window, at least to a degree. I wasn't trying to divert the conversation, just saying that even if a tuner is "made" for guitar, I think most of them tune to equal temperament. There are tuners that tune to "sweetened" tunings, notably the Peterson Strobe tuners, at least some of them. That's very common with steel guitars.
And I'm sorry if I sound argumentative, guitar intonation is something I've spent a lot of time pondering and working on, I have written a whole software program to calculate compensation including nut compensation, but I still don't entirely have my head around it. My program got kind of byzantine and I'm still working on it but it's interesting.
And now I realize that I didn't actually include a setting for a zero fret. Anyway, it's an HTML thing that you download to your desktop. It might be interesting just seeing what's involved:
that's a cool idea, the open string compared the 12th fret thing.
I might suggest you actually do the 1st fret fretted compared to the 13th fret fretted, and compare that to the open string and the 12th, that would give you some measure of the issue with the stretching in the lower frets. Or 2nd to 14th. Or all 3.
I made this whole multi level Acoustic IR builder all by myself, and I'm a fucking idiot. Absolutely insane. And it seems to understand what I'm asking it and suggests better alternatives sometimes for acoustic stuff. Deeply frightening but also amazing.
I have some other programs I'm intending to market...if someone had made them 5 years ago they would absolutely be the industry standard but now, I dunno. The first one should come out next week or so. It's pretty mind blowing what it can do.
Intonation adjustments remind me of this joke (a better version was told to me by this guy Mike who trained me at David Gage's bass shop around 1999, but it is very useful for describing a lot of Lutherie conundrums.
Yossi goes to a tailor to try on a new custom-made suit. The first thing he notices is that the sleeves are too long. “No problem,” says the tailor. “Just bend them at the elbow and hold them out in front of you. See, now it’s fine.” “But the collar is up around my ears!” “It’s nothing. Just hunch your back a little…no, a little more…that’s it.” “But I’m stepping on my cuffs!” Yossi cries in desperation. “Nu, bend your knees a little to take up the slack. There you go. Look in the mirror — the suit fits perfectly.” So, twisted like a pretzel, Yossi lurches out onto the street. Janine and Suzy see him go by. “Oh look,” says Janine, “that poor man.” “Yes,” says Suzy, “but what a beautiful suit!”
Paul - Thank you for your response comment on my post of possible early GJ players maybe compensating for somewhat poor intonation by string bending "tremolo". Some good additional tuning ideas by you and other posters here that I will check out against my method. Also: A few times in the past I have posted a comment that wasn't properly related to a core topic discussion, so I will be more careful in the future.
cool man. I sort of assume that conversations will go all over the place but maybe I'm in the minority. It's an interesting idea, tbh I'm not nearly as knowledgeable about older playing styles. My goal is to make crazy in tune instruments but I do certainly wonder if they will sound not in the style sometimes. Lacking grit? Intonation is super weird. I have a friend who is absolutely obsessed with temperament and intonation and he bores the shit out of everyone talking about it.
Comments
It's wild. I did a bunch of really cool acoustics research in my MS program. But couldn't really do anything with it. Now I have a pretty impressive program almost finished that creates a room, a virtual mic array, and very realistically auralizes a source or a combination of sources into your room. I tried to do it 2.5 years ago. Now I have a full pro tools plugin that is fully functional. Still ironing out some kinks. Still a lot of work to get it done, but before it would have been a team of software engineers over a year, now it is just me over a couple months.
I also created a joke one knowb plug-in called "Total Commitment" - 2 settings, Bluegrass me, or Django me. They actually sound really good but there is something very funny in them ;0) I will put it up for free as soon as I get both the MAC and PC version done.
On a side note I think it is only 2-3 years where people like us will be able to do these things. Then it will become SOOOO easy everyone just gets there own software upon request customized to whatever they want to do whenever they want to do it. It still took me some knowledge to guide the AI into all the acoustics programs I made, but it really knew everything, just needed a human to help put some of the pieces together into something more useful.
http://byersguitars.com/intonation/
Classical guitar luthier Gregory Byers worked on compensated nuts/bridge saddles decades ago, using the physics and properties of classical strings and guitars, with experimental data. He came up with his system for improving intonation.. Similar work could be done with, say, Argie 10s and a 670mm scale, given nut height,action, and neck relief. Buzz Feiten also created a system (maybe not scientifically based.)
Your point about the bending seems entirely possible, I don't know. Zero fret guitars should in general be more in tune than a guitar with a nut theoretically but the straight compensation of a gypsy guitar kind of throws that out the window, at least to a degree. I wasn't trying to divert the conversation, just saying that even if a tuner is "made" for guitar, I think most of them tune to equal temperament. There are tuners that tune to "sweetened" tunings, notably the Peterson Strobe tuners, at least some of them. That's very common with steel guitars.
And I'm sorry if I sound argumentative, guitar intonation is something I've spent a lot of time pondering and working on, I have written a whole software program to calculate compensation including nut compensation, but I still don't entirely have my head around it. My program got kind of byzantine and I'm still working on it but it's interesting.
And now I realize that I didn't actually include a setting for a zero fret. Anyway, it's an HTML thing that you download to your desktop. It might be interesting just seeing what's involved:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1l8UMTcsG0eDYb1g3IhzwzdbZ4DgS5wyX/view?usp=sharing
that's a cool idea, the open string compared the 12th fret thing.
I might suggest you actually do the 1st fret fretted compared to the 13th fret fretted, and compare that to the open string and the 12th, that would give you some measure of the issue with the stretching in the lower frets. Or 2nd to 14th. Or all 3.
I like the idea.
I made this whole multi level Acoustic IR builder all by myself, and I'm a fucking idiot. Absolutely insane. And it seems to understand what I'm asking it and suggests better alternatives sometimes for acoustic stuff. Deeply frightening but also amazing.
I have some other programs I'm intending to market...if someone had made them 5 years ago they would absolutely be the industry standard but now, I dunno. The first one should come out next week or so. It's pretty mind blowing what it can do.
Here's my IR thing:
https://github.com/paulmcevoy75/acoustic-ir-studio
Intonation adjustments remind me of this joke (a better version was told to me by this guy Mike who trained me at David Gage's bass shop around 1999, but it is very useful for describing a lot of Lutherie conundrums.
Yossi goes to a tailor to try on a new custom-made suit. The first thing he notices is that the sleeves are too long. “No problem,” says the tailor. “Just bend them at the elbow and hold them out in front of you. See, now it’s fine.” “But the collar is up around my ears!” “It’s nothing. Just hunch your back a little…no, a little more…that’s it.” “But I’m stepping on my cuffs!” Yossi cries in desperation. “Nu, bend your knees a little to take up the slack. There you go. Look in the mirror — the suit fits perfectly.” So, twisted like a pretzel, Yossi lurches out onto the street. Janine and Suzy see him go by. “Oh look,” says Janine, “that poor man.” “Yes,” says Suzy, “but what a beautiful suit!”
Paul - Thank you for your response comment on my post of possible early GJ players maybe compensating for somewhat poor intonation by string bending "tremolo". Some good additional tuning ideas by you and other posters here that I will check out against my method. Also: A few times in the past I have posted a comment that wasn't properly related to a core topic discussion, so I will be more careful in the future.
cool man. I sort of assume that conversations will go all over the place but maybe I'm in the minority. It's an interesting idea, tbh I'm not nearly as knowledgeable about older playing styles. My goal is to make crazy in tune instruments but I do certainly wonder if they will sound not in the style sometimes. Lacking grit? Intonation is super weird. I have a friend who is absolutely obsessed with temperament and intonation and he bores the shit out of everyone talking about it.
that sort of stuff is incorporated in my program, it's very hard to figure out what's right.
This is a comparison of the nut compensation with three different methods, you can see that they are all over the place.