Just to keep the record straight, I think Django's rhythm playing is wizard, and that goes for this one too. But IMHO that is the only thing that works well on this cut.
The Magic really starts to happen when you can play it with your eyes closed
I think Grappelli could swing the violin better than anyone else. I don't think Eddie South was a particularly good jazz player. A great violinist but not a good jazzman. Perhaps Steph felt intimidated by his musicianship and classical background just as he was with Menuhin until he actually performed with him.
Django may have preferred Warlop but his playing leaves me cold.
The relation with Django and Bach was kept until the very last days of his life. In fact exactly two days before his death Django (as he was in Ginevra to play at the Kasino theater) went to meet the famous classical guitarist Jose de Aspiazu with a famous swiss jazz trumpeter (can't remember the name) to discuss the opportunity to prepare a big event named "GUITARE" for the year to come. The concert was to be half classical and half Jazz with Django and Jose playing each one a set.
Lupe de Aspiazu, Jose's daughter and extraordinary guitarist in his own right that was 8 years old in that time, told me that she clearly remembered that day: Django was a very nice man that asked his father to play Bach the whole evening long, it lasted hours and Django cried hearing that music. At the end asked to play something himself he said that he was sorry to be unable to play classical music due to his left hand and he explained how he played guitar with two fingers - he played "Nuages" for them (maybe for the last time in his life).
Comments
Django may have preferred Warlop but his playing leaves me cold.
youtube.com/user/TheTeddyDupont
Lupe de Aspiazu, Jose's daughter and extraordinary guitarist in his own right that was 8 years old in that time, told me that she clearly remembered that day: Django was a very nice man that asked his father to play Bach the whole evening long, it lasted hours and Django cried hearing that music. At the end asked to play something himself he said that he was sorry to be unable to play classical music due to his left hand and he explained how he played guitar with two fingers - he played "Nuages" for them (maybe for the last time in his life).